Turn on any news show and you’ll hear analysts and pundits forecasting economic doom and gloom. Their reports are filled with words and phrases like “economic downturn,” “soft economy,” and the dreaded “recession.” While the jury is still out about whether or not we’re really in a recession, now is a great time to recession-proof your fundraising effort.
Weak economies can be very helpful for nonprofits. During such times, organizations are forced to be leaner and more efficient. Then when the economy rebounds, they’re in a much better position to take advantage of it.
But economic downturns can also be perilous times for nonprofits. When faced with a recession, many nonprofits make bad choices that limit their growth. Some of these mistakes can prove fatal.
3 Mistakes to Avoid
How will this economic climate affect your favorite nonprofit? Will you fulfill your mission or will you fold? That depends on whether you make these deadly mistakes:
- spend less on fundraising
- become pessimistic
- apologize when you’re asking
Spend less on fundraising
Whether we like it or not, asking for money costs money. When you’re looking for budgets to trim, costly mailings and fundraising activities will seem like obvious opportunities. But exercise extreme caution.
Most fundraising efforts can be tweaked to improve their effectiveness. These tweaks can either reduce cost or increase money raised. But I’ve never seen a fundraising effort raise more money by being eliminated.
In a recent study I did, I discovered our organization’s direct mail program raised more money during the years we sent out more letters. This was counter-intuitive to me. I’d worked for a couple years to eliminate mailings and focus exclusively on the people deemed most likely to make a gift. But in that time of trying to cut expenses, our annual fund dropped by around 30%! Fortunately, this year we’ve increased our mailings and have already raised as much in six months as we did the entire previous year.
Spending less on fundraising can become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Less investment can result in less being raised which leads to further cuts and even less raised. Tighten budgets where necessary but be very careful when making cuts to fundraising programs.
The top fundraising professionals are some of the most optimistic people alive. The minute they start being gloomy, people begin holding on to their wallets. Ever wonder why the stock market drops when pundits prophesy uncertainty? No one wants to invest in a questionable deal. It’s the same sort of self-fulfilling loop with fundraising.
As development professionals, we’re inviting people to invest in our mission. Our cause makes the world a better place regardless of the economy! That’s not going to change. We need to continue to shed light on the good things happening around us. We don’t need to be Pollyanna, but we do need to continue to see the silver lining.
Apologizing when you’re asking
When we keep hearing how bad things are, it’s easy to get awkward about asking for donations. But timidity is a sure-fire way to not raise money. We need to continue getting out from behind our desks and inviting donors to give.
I’m certainly not advocating being brash or arrogant. We do need to understand that many of our donors may not be able to give at the same level. This is where we can be compassionate and understanding. And our relaxed understanding of people’s financial realities can make them even stronger proponents of our organizations in the future.
But there’s nothing compassionate about not asking.
Stay Positive and Succeed
Whether the economy is soft or strong, one sure way to raise less money is to stop asking for it! The best way to recession-proof your fundraising is to keep doing the things that raises money and to do it in a way that strengthens relationships with donors, helping them become evangelists for your cause:
- keep on making wise investments in fundraising efforts,
- stay upbeat, and
- continue to compassionately raise support.
Combine these ingredients and you have an excellent recipe for strengthening your nonprofit fundraising in any economy!
About the Author: Marc A. Pitman, CFCC is the author of Ask Without Fear! and the founder of Fundraisingcoach.com. His fundraising books and nonprofit seminars specialize in helping fundraising executives reconnect with their passion.
This article is part of the Fundraising in Challenging Economic Times series.
Here’s a list of each of the articles in this series:
- Recession Proof Fundraising by Anisha Robinson Keeys
- 3 Suggestions for Raising Money in Tough Economic Times by Jim Berigan
- When Foundations Say “No” by Aaron Atwood
- Succeed at Fundraising Despite a Recession by Marc Pitman